How Crowded Is Fire Island in September?
September is a busy month at Fire Island National Seashore, running about 1.4× the park's average month — roughly 12% of the year's visitors come in September. That puts it between the August peak and the January low. Overall our best-time score rates September as "Good" for a visit. Typical September weather averages a high near 73°F and a low around 61°F, with about 4.4" of precipitation. You'll get about 12.3 hours of daylight to explore.
Frequently Asked Questions
September is busy at Fire Island National Seashore (about 1.4× the average month). Our best-time score rates it "Good". The single best month overall is May.
The busiest month is August and the quietest is January. September sits at about 1.4× the park's average, or 12% of annual visitation.
Source: National Park Service Visitor Use Statistics (1979–2025), NOAA NCEI Climate Normals 1991–2020. Updated 2026-06-20.